Summary
- PM Modi claimed Centre allocated three times more funds to Tamil Nadu between 2014–24 than in the previous decade.
- Former Finance Minister P Chidambaram questioned the economic validity of such comparisons, calling them statistically misleading.
- The row comes amid growing tensions between the BJP-led Centre and DMK-led Tamil Nadu over developmental fund distribution.
𝐏𝐌 𝐂𝐀𝐑𝐄𝐒 or BJP CARES FUND ?
— তন্ময় l T͞anmoy l (@tanmoyofc) March 23, 2024
Rs 30 Crore TikTok
Rs 7 Crore Huawei
Rs 15 Crore Xiaomi
Rs 100 Crore PayTM
Rs 203 Crore Armed Forces (from their Salaries)
Rs 204 Crore Public Sector Banks
Rs 21 Crores Teachers and Employees of Central Educational Institutions
Rs 2,100 Crore… pic.twitter.com/2z0E8163Dt
Modi vs Chidambaram: War of Numbers Over Tamil Nadu’s Share of Central Funds
New Delhi | April 7, 2025 — A political spat over development spending has reignited tensions between the Centre and Tamil Nadu, as former Finance Minister P Chidambaram publicly dismissed Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s claim that the central government allocated three times more funds to the state between 2014 and 2024 compared to the UPA decade.
The former Union minister’s remarks came shortly after PM Modi’s speech in Tamil Nadu, where he emphasized that increased central support had “greatly contributed to Tamil Nadu’s economic and industrial growth,” despite, in his words, “some still crying foul over funds.”
The Numbers Game: Is “More” Actually Better?
- Modi claimed central funding for railways in Tamil Nadu rose sevenfold under NDA compared to UPA years.
- Chidambaram countered that absolute increases are expected due to inflation, economic expansion, and rising government expenditure.
- He questioned whether the rise was proportional to GDP or total government outlay.
Chidambaram, who served as Finance Minister under both UPA I and II, emphasized that rising numerical allocations are inevitable over time.
“The GDP is bigger now. The size of the central budget is bigger now. The total government expenditure is bigger now. So of course the numbers will be higher,” he stated.
He challenged the Centre to disclose whether Tamil Nadu’s share of central funds had actually increased as a proportion of total allocations or remained stagnant in real terms after adjusting for inflation.
DMK’s Stand and the Regional Discontent
- The DMK, currently leading the Tamil Nadu government, has long accused the Centre of neglecting southern states in fund allocations and tax devolution.
- Tamil Nadu is among the top contributor states to India’s GDP but often receives less in return via central grants, the DMK argues.
- Modi’s remarks were seen as a rebuttal to these accusations, made during his recent visit to the state.
Despite Modi’s claims of increased central support, tensions remain high. The DMK-led government has repeatedly highlighted perceived fiscal unfairness, especially regarding Finance Commission recommendations, GST compensation shortfalls, and infrastructure funding delays.
Political Optics Ahead of 2026 State Elections
- Modi’s Tamil Nadu visit comes as the BJP eyes expanding its base in the South, a region where it has historically struggled.
- Chidambaram’s rebuttal underscores the Congress-DMK narrative that the Centre is using “big numbers” to mask policy imbalance.
- The BJP hopes increased visibility and infrastructure announcements will counter anti-incumbency claims and win regional trust.
Modi’s speech, invoking figures and highlighting development projects, was framed as part of the Centre’s commitment to a “Developed India by 2047” — a theme being increasingly integrated into BJP’s pre-election messaging.
Final Word: Optics vs. Economics
Chidambaram’s intervention highlights a broader point about how economic data is used in political narratives. While absolute increases in central allocations may appear impressive, contextual benchmarks like GDP share, inflation-adjusted value, and regional equity matter more in assessing fairness and impact.
With 2026 state elections drawing nearer, the debate over funds, federalism, and fairness is likely to intensify — not just in Tamil Nadu, but across other southern states watching how the Centre treats contributors versus dependents in India’s fiscal federation.
